HR Puts the “Relations” in “Labour Relations”

HR and Unions: The Ever Changing Relationship

Portrait of a man giving an handshake in an industrial facility
Minerva Studio/Shutterstock

HR needs to always expand its knowledge base. Whether you are hesitant to work with unions or accepting of the union’s philosophy, it is always good to listen to what an iconic union leader has to say about how to improve workplace relationships, and in this case union-management relations.

Buzz Hargrove is one of the most prominent union leaders that Canada has ever seen. He spent over 40 years working in the trenches of Canadian Labour Relations with much of that time as President of the Canadian Autoworkers Workers Union (now Uniform).

Click here to know more about Buzz Hargrove.

Depending on how the HR department integrates itself with the union they will have drastically diametric outcomes and relationships within the organization. From the video interview clip done by the Canadian HR Reporter, Buzz gives HR advice on work with a union which includes the following:

  • Open daily communication
  • Positive union-management relationships reduces costs
  • HR working with the union members makes a difference
  • Spending time and sharing information with the union will pay off
  • Most of all, according to Buzz , HR has to have integrity

Click here is to watch the video clip.

Even if you never plan on working directly in an unionized environment it is always wise as an HR professional to understand how unions work and how unionization will affect the day to day operations of the workplace.

Discussion Questions:

  1. Research what happened with Buzz Hargrove over the closing of the Molson Plant in Barrie Ontario in 1999.
  2. If you were the leader of Molson’s HR department during the above event, what would your recommended response be?

Click here to start your research.

Patterned Collective Bargaining 

Close-up of business meeting
Dragon Images/Shutterstock

What is good for one is not always good for the other!

To become a seasoned HR professional one needs to know not only the basics but understand the complexities of union management relationships. Having an understanding of patterned bargaining is one of those invaluable HR insights that will boost your HR career.

Collective Bargaining negotiations are always a complex dance between two parties. In many cases it involves not just the union and management at a single negotiations table but will include other employers that are represented by the same union. That has been the case for collective bargaining in the Auto Manufacturing Industry with Ford, GM and Chrysler in Ontario for decades. However, that may be changing in this round of negotiations

What is patterned bargaining? According to their own documentation the CAW (now Unifor) in its bargaining philosophy explains patterned bargaining on page 62 of the 2008 Collective Bargaining and Political Action Convention report as the following:

“In pattern bargaining we focus our efforts at negotiating a deal in one location that can be applied to other workplaces. Pattern bargaining is our attempt to overcome the limits of an industrial relations model built on collective agreements that apply to a single location or a specific employer. In some situations the pattern agreement is virtually the same across companies, as is the case in our bargaining at GM, Ford and Chrysler.”

Typically the union, in this case Unifor, will target a specific automaker where the union feels it can get the best deal. When a new collective agreement is obtained with the targeted employer the other employers will accept the deal as a “me too” agreement and they do not have to spend time to go through the negotiation process nor have a threat of a labour disruption. One could say it is a win/win situation and keeps the collective agreement consistent across the industry.

For the current 2016 round of auto industry labour negotiations, Unifor targeted GM in Oshawa as the primary employer to begin negotiations. In September 2016 the parties successfully reached a deal. This agreement would normally set the pattern for other agreements to follow and labour talks would be completed with the other two employers.

Here is where the twist happens, Unifor may not follow patterned bargaining nor have the ability to settle with the same GM deal for Ford and Chrysler as has been the precedent. This round the President of the Union Local  707 representing Ford employees in Oakville states he “is not prepared to accept the template that secured a deal with General Motors.”

Dave Thomas the Unifor Local 707 president goes further on to state:

“We as a local bargaining committee have sent a very clear message to Ford Motor Company and the national union that the framework agreement between GM and the membership will not suit the needs of the membership in Oakville.”

Click here to read greater details of the Oakville Ford Local Unions’ position.

This is a very interesting turn of events; the auto workers’ union has been very successful in the past by having a united front and a common focus. This has been their bargaining philosophy for decades, but just how the manufacturing industry has been dramatically changed by globalization, so too may the concept of patterned bargaining in the Auto Sector.

Discussion Questions

  1. What are the benefits and negatives for an industry to follow the concept of patterned bargaining?
  2. What are the benefits and negatives for an union to follow the concept of patterned bargaining?
  3. Research and identify if there are any other unions and industries in Canada that follow the philosophy of patterned bargaining

 

 

 

 

 

Let’s Celebrate Labour Day, eh?

A History Worth Understanding.

Every day that they put this legislation off to the future is more time to negotiate.”   –    Sid Ryan.

 As Canadians, we enjoy a remarkable history related to the development of unions and the labour movement.   This historic past is built on the need for social change that provides a future benefit to all of us as workers in Canada.   Most of Canadian labour history provides evidence of our more peaceful natures as powerful union leaders; such as, Sid Ryan’s use effective negotiation skills to achieve legislative changes.  There are however, critical moments in our collective history based on violence and turbulent times.  All of this history continues to be celebrated annually on Labour Day, which is a statutory Canadian federal holiday.

The importance of Labour Day and its connection to the history of the labour movement is highlighted in the following article:

Click here to read the article

Since this article was first published, in 2009, there have been numerous legislative changes that have continued to improve the lives of Canadian workers as a result of the drive and dedication of the labour movement in Canada.  The future of the labour movement in Canada is built on numerous significant events from the past.

Unions have drastically altered our society and our economy. We have all benefited from the labour movement for such things as workplace safety, greater vacation, and maternity and parental leave benefits.  When we remember the past and think about the future, do we want to live in an economy or do we want to live in a society with an economy? Unions support the latter and continue to change history as a result.

Clearly, history does not stop.   It provides us with pictures of moments in time that we may not recognize as important when they are happening. Labour Day provides us with an opportunity to celebrate our collective labour history, reflect on those important moments in time, and to honour our past as we look to the future.

Discussion Questions:

  1. This article is dated from 2009. Identify new workplace legislation that has been implemented since that time either federally or in the province where you live. What is the link between each piece of new legislation and the labour movement?
  2. What types of workplace benefits do you enjoy as a result of the labour movement in Canada?
  3. Which historic labour-related event do you think has had the most impact on the lives of Canadian workers?
  4. How do you celebrate labour day?
  5. Will you participate in the next Labour Day parade in your community? Why or why not?
  6. What would prompt you to participate in a Labour Day parade?